After sitting out overnight, disaster struck my custom Dave Eilers cut autograph.
So yes, a gross overstatement. But nonetheless, there is a flaw in my process. I am assuming it was a combination of too little glue and not enough time under pressure. Not all is lost though, I can take it apart. I hope.
This is why I started by using Dave Eilers and not Yogi Berra. This time I used a whole lot more glue and am leaving it in the book overnight. Here is what it looks like all put back together.
So still looks pretty good. The borders are cut a little off center in comparison, but that can really only be seen from holding the two cards in my hand. I will update how well this one stays together.